Creamy and Rich: Homemade Ricotta

As a kid, since I can remember to about when I was 14 I spent me entire Summer break in a small village in Poland with my dad’s family. They didn’t have running water (just a well). We bathed in a huge washbowl and…  the toilet was outside. I would eat wild growing berries and drank milk straight from a cow. For two months I would forget how processed food tastes like. During the last few years we visited them they had a store (!). That tiny place was mostly used for buying an alcohol and sodas by locals. It didn’t last long, though. That’s how self-sufficient that village was (as most of the villages anywhere else in Poland).

One of the best memories I have from that period is milking cows. I was never good at it and I gave up very quickly in trying to get better, but I tried it and it was fun. While my aunty was milking her cows I would pretend I’m a cat and I tried to drink that warm and fresh milk straight from a bucket to which my aunty milked the cows. Once, a friend of our family came from behind while I was doing so and pushed my head deep inside that filled with milk bucket. Everybody laughed and I was mad… . I’ve never drank milk straight from a bucket since.

Despite that accident and many more (like me being attacked by a “gang” of angry turkeys) those 2 months spent there every year were the best times ever. I will cherish them forever.

The food we ate there is my goal to achieve in the future: home grown, home raised, homemade.

Right now I just learn how to “home make” stuff from what I can get at the store 🙂

This time I learned how to make ricotta.

I’ll tell you something: I will never buy ricotta again. The homemade is creamy, rich and nothing like the store-bought. NOTHING! The recipe I got is not the original ricotta recipe. The original calls for whey from making another cheese (like mozzarella). Whole milk is never used. I cheated here a little 😉 It doesn’t matter, I think. The results are amazing and that’s what matters. Right?!

To make it I used:

3 cups whole milk

1 cup heavy cream*

1/2 tsp salt

4 Tbsp fresh squeezed lemon juice

Directions that couldn’t be any easier:

Pour the milk, cream and salt into a saucepan. If you have a candy or deep-fry thermometer attach it to the pan and heat the milk to 190°F stirring occasionally. When it reaches 190°F remove from heat.

If you do not have the thermometer you should watch the milk-cream very closely until you see bubbles appearing around the edges of the pot. It means the liquid is ready to be removed from heat.

Add lemon juice. Stir couple of times (no more), very gently and slowly. Let the pot sit undisturbed for 5 to 10 minutes.

Line a sieve with a few layers of cheesecloth and place it over a bowl. The bowl is to catch the whey. Later it can be used for baking breads.

Pour the milk mixture into the sieve and let the curds strain for at least an hour.

I didn’t have cheesecloth (but I do now) so I used an old t-shirt I don’t use anymore.

The cheese I got after 2 hours of straining was firm but very easy spreadable, it looked and felt almost like cream cheese. No curds just creamy and silky texture.

I am not sure for how long you can store it. I kept mine in airtight container in the fridge. It lasted for 4 days before I ate it all.

I ate it with fresh baked bread… .

You can’t beat that!

For an extra twist to this cheese visit Polish Mama on the Prairie… I’m definitely trying her idea the next time I’ll make it.

* the heavy cream in this recipe can be skipped. doing so you’ll get cheese with big curds and much more drier texture. 

It's a KeeperHookingupwithHoH Beyond The Picket Fence

26 responses to “Creamy and Rich: Homemade Ricotta”

  1. Looks lovely. I’ll make sure Samantha gets it. 🙂


    1. thank you, Jennifer! If you make it or Samantha, let me know how it came out. I hope you both like it as I do!!!


      1. Will do. I especially liked it on that homemade bread! Mmmmm….


          1. Another one for the recipe box! (And I really enjoyed the story of you drinking out of the bucket and your wonderful summer memories and the fact your goal is to eat like that again. The entire village must be so healthy–and wise!) One day I will visit Poland. I’ve wanted to since I read “The girl in the red coat.” The way she described the food still sticks out in my mind. Especially the hot chocolate with whipped cream. Funny the things you remember.
            And then I met you!


            1. I never read that book. I just finished what I’d been reading. Time to go to a library. thanks for the idea!


  2. The last time I tried making something like this, it failed. But I’m going to try with local milk since it’s fresher. You keep inspiring me, Mama! I hope one day we can meet and cook together 🙂


    1. maybe you cooked milk for too long or it was too cold. I don’t have the thermometer but I watched that milk very closely until it started to simmer and bubbles around the edges appeared and imidiately I took it off of the heat. worked great.
      It would be awesome to meet and cook: Two Polish Mammas cooking and chatting 🙂


  3. Thank you for linking this! I shared it on my FB wall!


  4. This looks yummy! Next time I get some raw milk I’m going to make it!


    1. I bet it’s gonna be delicious with raw milk!!!


  5. Thank you so much for this recipe! I am just venturing into the world of cheesemaking and this recipe is a great place for me to start. Looks so delicious!
    Thanks for linking up to my “Made from Scratch” blog hop and look forward to hearing from you every Saturday!
    The Way Grandmama Does it


    1. who would have thought that making cheese will be that simple and fast. of course it’s not the real process and ingredients for a real cheese but it’s a good start and better that the store bought.


  6. I did this once and added herbs for a really nice cracker spread too! I never thought about using it for my lasagna like store bought ricotta but it would be perfect!


    1. that’s a great idea: herbs!!! thanks 🙂


  7. That looks so delicious! My first cheese making adventure ended up being a complete disaster……lets just say I made cheese crumbles and I have been afraid to test the waters since…but maybe I will your recipe certainly looks like something I can handle…you know my mantra is “Keep It Simple” ;)…. I love the idea about saving money for lasagna! Thanks for linking up to The Ole’ Saturday Homesteading Trading Post again at Lil’ Suburban Homestead! Oh and your pictures are amazing too as always!


    1. I like your mantra. I try to go with it as well. I know that if you don’t use heavy cream you will end up with cheese that have crumbs. this one is really creamy almost like a cream cheese. It’s really worth a try!


  8. Brilliant! I can’t wait to try this. Thanks so much for sharing.


    1. let me know how you like it 🙂


  9. Your cheese turned out so well! It looks great and this is a fabulous tutorial! Thanks for sharing it with the HnS Hop.


  10. Amazing! No idea you could make cheese at home so easy! Thanks for linking up at DIY Thrifty Thursdays at Thrifty 101….you’ve been featured! Be sure to stop by and grab an “I was Featured button”. Hope to see you again this week! 🙂



    1. wow! great!! thank you so much for the feature!


  11. […] For the next two days we ate the rest of the buns for lunch with some veggies and homemade ricotta. […]


  12. This is a super post. Thanks for linking it to Food on Friday. Do pop back in a few days to have a look at the collection of all things cheesy.


Don’t be shy and let me know what’s hiding in your head!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: